Out of the 2 witch one do you like [quote=“JoeyZ5, post:108, topic:50988, full:true”]
You will need a loopkey/antispark for the Maker X though.
[/quote]
2 Likes
I’d use a loopkey on either one, or any any ESC, even if it has a soft switch.
You don’t have to unplug the key, but having the option is nice 
The Spintend does 17S and the MakerX does 12S max
2 Likes
I think the extra $80 for the spintend is worth it. You get a remote, antispark, and those cool horn/light ports.
Edit: and bluetooth
3 Likes
Spintend Ubox will retain resale value better as well
4 Likes
i thought they removed the AS in the later version?
3 Likes
I just looked at the spintend, that’s the one I’m going to go with. Anybody have personal experience with that one?
1 Like
I used it on my 12S MTB build. Actually pretty similar to your setup, with two 14Ah LiPos and dual 6374s. No complaints with it, the remote’s pretty nice and everything was plug and play. Integrated Bluetooth is surprisingly useful, as I can now make changes to the VESC configuration without having to pop open the enclosure. It’s a little larger than some of the other ESCs out there thanks to the heat sink/enclosure, but not terribly so, especially if you cut off the tabs on the side.
Only thing I haven’t been able to figure out is how to get reverse working without changing the input mode in setup, but it’s not a huge deal since the number of times I’ve actually needed it in the past two years have been exactly 0.
1 Like
Yeah I remember hearing that at some point now
2 Likes
AS had been replaced with an XT90S connector, which isn’t too annoying. If you never unplug the battery you can just use the button to turn it on.
1 Like
I’ll have to figure out reverse. Sometimes it’s nice to be able to back up if you end up in the middle of the street when you have to slam on the brakes:yum:
Anyone know current consumption with the unit off?
1 Like
Any of the escs use very very little power when totally idle I calculated it once and was like a week or something to drain a relatively small (185Wh pack). For the long long term you are saving cycles by disconnecting things but the stm32 processor power consumption is pretty minimal even if it’s maxing out which it usually isn’t.
Can hook up a multimeter inline to check just don’t pull the throttle think I checked off bench power supply amp draw too at the time.
2 Likes
I know the processor uses very little power in sleep mode, but some antispark circuits use so much power they can drain a decent pack in a few weeks.
2 Likes
Ah for like 5 min there was trying to figure out how xt-90S could drain power once fully plugged in then realized you mean more complicated antispark circuits or soft/kick start systems
3 Likes
Y’all are awesome and extremely helpful! I finally went with 2 6s 13000mah 30c lipos, a smart BMS and the Spintend. Now I’m like a little Kid on Christmas waiting for that morning to come so I can tear open my packages. Lipos come in Monday and Spintend later in the week hopefully 
1 Like
Nice. Start a build thread and we can all help you set it up. Which lipos did you go with in the end?
1 Like
I went with the Ononics. They seemed to be a decent price and was recommended.
I’ll start the build thread after I’ve received everything.
What BMs did you go with? Where did you find the lipos?