I’ve been wondering about this, tossing it out for discussion…
I can understand wanting a high balance current rating if putting together a new pack, for the initial balancing, but very little current is needed for balancing after that.
Over time the BMS just needs to compensate for the differences in leakage current rates between the cells/p-groups since this is what causes the imbalance. These differences are a lot less than 1mA for new (round Li-ion) cells.
There’s nothing we can do about the difference in capacity between the cells/p-groups resulting in them dropping voltage at different rates. There’s nothing we can do about the difference in internal resistance between the cells/p-groups, causing different amounts of voltage sag (during discharge) or voltage rise (during charge).
The BMS just has to do its job to keep any cell/p-group from going too high or low in voltage and protect against overcurrent and short-circuits.
So why do we want more than a few mA of balancing current per cell?
If we want it to help balance a new pack quickly then we’re paying more for a larger BMS that generates a lot of heat just to use once or twice.
If we want a lot of current to quickly rebalance a pack that’s been in storage for a very long time are we willing to pay more and deal with a larger BMS just for that rare occurrence?
If we want it to help compensate for aging cells, which self-discharge and become unbalanced faster, then we are forcing ourselves to run a pack with badly performing cells that will have also lost a lot of capacity and will have more voltage sag. Why try to keep those cells balanced? In my opinion it’s better to replace them, or the pack, than to desperately try to keep crappy performing cells balanced.
A technical concern…the higher the balancing current the longer the cells need to rest, after balancing current flows, in order to come to their true resting voltage. If the BMS doesn’t take this into account then the balancing accuracy will suffer. Whether this makes a practical difference depends on the cells, the current level, etc.
So, why do we want more balancing current from a BMS?
How much balancing current do we really need?
Just thinking out loud…I’d love to hear your thoughts on this!