Why do we even need to disconnect the VESC from batteries?

Why do we need to disconnect the VESCs from the battery (using antispark switch / xt90s loop key or any other solution)?

why can’t we just leave the VESC turned ON and simply turn off the remote?

Communicating with Flipsky, they say
Idle consumption of the vesc is ~16mWh.

even with my tiny 10s2p - 144Wh battery, such tiny consumption can last over a year (375 days).

So draining the battery is not a reason.

what else is to be concerned to avoid simply leaving it ON all the time and bypass any complicated switch to disconnect the vesc off?

2 Likes

Nobody make you to disconnect the esc from the battery when you don’t drive anymore. :sweat_smile:

5 Likes

English is not my native language, don’t catch me on the wording…
I meant why does one do that? what for?

I mean it like I said. You can just let the esc connected to the battery if you want.
Only thing is that there is still a energy consumption. Maybe also from your bt-module.
So something you should non the less have an eye on. Especially if you come home with an close to empty battery and than don’t drive for weeks.

4 Likes

Some remotes (cough Nano X cough) require calibration before you ride. Being able to turn the board off for this is useful.

It also stops people who randomly find your remote and turn it on from destroying your wall.
(for the life of me I can’t remember who that happened to, otherwise I would share the picture)

4 Likes

Once I forgot to switch off my MTB and the lipos were almost empty (400Wh). 2 or 3 days later the battery was over-discharged and had some dead cells (0V). That was a hard lesson.

If you always charge when you reach home and ride within a couple of days plus monitor the voltage it is possible to leave it on. The thing is you need to disconnect the esc’s anyway in case of longer breaks (e.g. winter) as long as you don’t check voltage (and charge) all the time.

Or you are just the first in this community who can’t switch off his esk8 :man_shrugging:

2 Likes

Using a loopkey gives me a piece of mind knowing the battery is completely disconnected from everything.

5 Likes

Yea, peace of mind.

I left mine on for about 3 months while I was waiting for the new flipsky smart antispark with auto turn on function, but I was constantly checking the battery voltage. Had some anxiety that some unforseen thing was going to happen. Also I think the idle current draw is a bit more than that IRL because there was a significant voltage decrease after a day and I run a 12s4p

I frequently don’t pull the loop key out for months on end of certain skates I ride a lot. But they are connected to a charger… if the charger were to die, the skate would slowly discharge until the battery was destroyed. It’s a risk. I never have ALL the skates on, typically one or two because laziness.

3 Likes

You leave your boards charging 24/7? Thats no good.

8 Likes

Liions, LifePO4 and LiPo all degrade after a couple weeks stored at full charge, I feel you it sucks total ass having to wait an hour if you realize you need something and its even more of a pain in the ass if you have to balance your pack at 1-4A when you don’t have a board to eat up voltage but you’re placing it into storage for the winter. However I lost 10% of my 8Ah’s LiFePO4s capacity when I left them at 3.6v for a month, I’ll never make that mistake again.

Use it as a 5Ah lifepo4 and you won’t have any issues. It’s over capacity
Like I said, “defective”

2 Likes

Its not over capacity, it keeps 100% capacity through 1000 charge cycles and 80% at 1500 cycles, they just aren’t meant to be used like that, wasting 40% of your battery capacity isn’t a solution, not leaving it 100% charged is the solution.

Not leaving it 100% charged is like you leaving your car with no gas in it inside the garage.

Fuck that.

I’m keeping it fully charged and if it doesn’t work right, I will shitcan it and get another battery. Because in that scenario, the battery is not doing the job I have placed it there to do.

6 Likes

Different strokes, I’m happy to leave my batteries at 30-40% charge and add an hour of time before I have to leave to relax and let my shit charge, I aint in a hurry but I’m always russian.

1 Like

In the end, it’s very, very. very unlikely that you will wear out the battery anyway, before something else has broken to take it out of service sooner. Unlike cars, we don’t have a century of top-dollar engineering into reliability. esk8 today are at the point cars were at in 1897 LoL

2 Likes

He fundamentally rejected a loop key when I suggested it on the other forum.

1 Like

I am using this ATM, and it’s working great.

2 Likes

Which other forum?

:blush:

3 Likes