Reducing weight in ESK8

I have given that a fair bit of priority.
To me a slimmer build is often nicer looking.
Looking back at the @whitepony days. It think keeping it clean & slim was I think was part of why his builds looked so nice back then.

4 Likes

I took a crack at building the lightest 2wd mtb possible. The compromise is you get like 15 miles of range max, but still… 27 pounds is pretty crazy light.

If you put an acceptable range battery in it (20s4p), you also have to go with a larger box, and then you’re at 37 pounds, which is not so light.

Anyone see a place to cut some grams?

weight count total weight
Prototype Mtb Deck 2200 1 2200
18s2p battery (583wh) 3200 1 3200
radium belt drive kit 283 2 566
newbee rtkp 751 2 1502
Flipsky 6354 140kv motors 460 2 920
MBS T3 tires 235 4 940
inner tubes 80 4 320
Hubba hubs 193 4 772
Pelican 1120 607 1 607
mbs f5 bindings + heel straps 580 1 580
Bearings 20 8 160
ESC 330 1 330
12.1 Kg
26.7 Lbs

Possible changes
Rockstar ii hubs
Junction box for battery box

7 Likes

Thats not bad. Lipos are a good option for low weight I think they have higher gravimetric energy density than li-ion and you’d want the discharge with a small pack.

Are matrix iii lighter than newbee rtkp?

Matrix iii are a few grams heavier

I was surprised to learn this, but lipos are actually significantly worse in terms of wh/kg vs lithium ion cylindrical cells. The reason some people still run them is the high energy delivery with less sag compared to cylindrical cells.

  • p45b = 231 wh/kg
  • normal lipo packs = ~150wh/kg

The place lipos may be a good choice is if you’re tight on space. If you’re building a brick pack, the wh/liter for lipos is better. If you’re building a stagger pack, the wh/liter is better for lithium ion cells.

@ducktaperules did a fantastic write up here on wh/liter:

and batterymooch has this to say about lipos

4 Likes

What are the battery dimensions plus esc (everything in da box)

Or rather, what’s the max size needed to hold it all

Fivestars are 164g a piece vs hubba

1 Like

On the topic of weight reduction, things like deck material, thickness, battery power to density, motor weight and even wheels will make a difference. One of my builds that i originally built for stealth, ended up being too heavy when i did a 10s3p, should’ve done a 10s2p instead as the deck contributed a lot of weight.

2 Likes

mtb with hoyt 5in, if u can steal those nylon version off @BenjaminF
also titanium everything, ask @poastoast how much weight he saved when he went full titanium

1 Like

Something like an end grain balsa-cored composite deck can be half the weight of a conventional wooden one, but IDK about longevity of something like that.

2 Likes

Pelican 1120 looks like the ideal jump pack size. You can fit a 18s2p p42a pack, or a 18s3p p28a pack. In both configs you end up with basically identical weight (2520g of cells) and 544wh. Imo 18s2p of p45b would be the way to go here. 18650s are stupid expensive for some reason.

The 18650 config would give you an extra 5mm of space on top, so that might be useful if you were trying to jam the esc in there too.

Slightly larger junction box I found is 440g. Not for everyone but mine have taken a beating and haven’t budged. Worth considering if you want to go ultra light maybe :person_shrugging:

1 Like

200g off is significant. What is the box?

LeMotech Waterproof Dustproof IP67 Junction Box DIY Case Enclosure Gray 7.9 x 5.9 x 3.9 inch (200 x 150 x 100 mm) Amazon.com

Just one example.

“DIY junction box” is the key search term

1 Like

I think wheels are the most worthwhile component to tackle weight on since it is directly related to acceleration and braking. Tomiboi has a nice set of hubs out there made of fiber reinforced nylon. Maybe a carbon reinforced nylon or thermoplastic? Also, hubs look like they have material on them that could be whittled away while maintaining good strength and durability.

Trucks are probably another good place to focus on for weight savings. If you look at the Stooge 3-link truck, for example, the hanger/axle is a solid piece of steel. May be hollow steel axle with a 15mm or 18mm diameter would be lighter and stiffer.

I think the high quality components in the bicycle industry have lots of weigh-saving solutions.

1 Like

Rockstar nylon hubs are 165g each, and are adequate. Matrix IIs might be lighter with the nylon baseplate (IIRC each nylon baseplate is 115g lighter than a metal baseplate). F5 bindings are pretty chunky compared to the cheaper foam/nylon ones, although you’re trading off weight for comfort. You could also probably save some weight by shaping the deck a bit, but that’s starting to get to the extremes.

2 Likes

Here’s a question I’ve had for a while, and this seems like a good enough place to ask it.

Is there any avenue where more smaller motors results is less weight than fewer larger motors, for equivalent speed/power?

And what are the big factors that push things one way or the other?

1 Like

I think it really depends on how hard you want to push and what kind of riding you plan to do. Larger motors can handle more amps and generally stay cool better. So hilly, high sustained speeds probably fair better with larger motors. But if you’re mainly cruising not doing heavy hills or acceleration I think you can get away with smaller motors.

My own observation. I think 4x 6355 motor are more than enough for most things. But is that lighter than 2x6385, not sure.

1 Like

Certain motors can handle more power than others. I had a pair of Reacher 6455 motors with 70 amps that had no issues. I have hear of reacher 6485 can handle well over 100amps. There is some room for weight savings in the motor department.

I wonder if titanium instead of steel gears would work for pulleys and gear drives.

1 Like

I keep my boards simple, which is lighter. BUT, I really don’t care about weight. I do care about trueness, balance, and stability. I find that I compensate by HYPERMILING. I anticipate stops and starts. Start off slow and brake slowly. Maintain my momentum.

1 Like

Weight’s a pretty big deal on an MTB though because the bindings let you jump and lift the board around. Jumping a 35lb board is significantly harder than jumping a 17lb board, both in the strength needed to lift it and controlling it in midair.

2 Likes