PROJECT: ENDGAME a karting inspired raceboard's development

Couple updates:

Spent a day redesigning the swingarm for CNC machining (not a simple job however not impossible to machine either). From 8.9kg alu the end result is 2.3kg for both. With some FEA I might look into more weight savings but I’m happy enough with this number for moment.

Working on acquiring a cnc mill. In the meantime the university lab just got a makera carvera air, so if my own mill takes too much time to acquire and setup, mayyybe I can cut it at uni. The 130mm Z axis travel on that small machine might make some operations impossible though. The 160mm on the ratrig would be doable but I’d appreciate 200mm Z if I can find something like that…

A set of swingarms is 200€ in raw material (7075 alu), damn, was hoping it would be about half of that. Maybe i’ll cut it in wood first to make sure I won’t mess it up :smile:

11 Likes

Not a bad thought !

Lol

2 Likes

I had a Carvera Air for a bit. How big are the pieces you are looking to mill? Looking at it in photos, I don’t know that you’d be able to do the holes in the sides because it doesn’t look like you’d have the Z clearance.

Also you would most definitely want a 3D probe setup with a good vise, and they’d need to be running the Carvera community firmware in order to use the probe. It would definitely be better on a larger mill.

1 Like

It also makes me happy to see that Tomiboi deck still tearing it up over there :tada:

1 Like

About 170x100x40. Definitely at the very least suboptimal on the carvera but likely impossible to make those bearing seats with that machine.

I am in the process of acquiring a much, much beefier mill from 1988:

400x400x100 travels. The Z axis I am going to upgrade for around 200mm travel (need to see what’s the max reasonable), need to mill plates, find ball screw kit and linear guides, but should definitely be something that I can do. The electronics all go to the junk bin and the plan is fitting modern electronics, thinking of some cheap mach3 controller or the like, I already have some decent nema23 closed loop steppers to modernize the current motion system, just need to make some sort of adapters for them (on the carvera), and a basic spindle mount adapter (on the carvera) for probably one of the generic 2.2kW spindles, which I over time will probably want to upgrade to something beefier with ATC.

Once that’s done this machine can cut it’s own bigger Z axis, and after that I can get to work on the swingarm. So I definitely have some busy weeks/ months ahead.

Oh and this monster is about 800kg/ 1750lbs, so I gotta figure out the hard part too, which is transport (over like 900km/ 600miles) and moving it to it’s place.

5 Likes

I’m honestly very suprised how well it takes the insane amount of abuse I give it! Love the ride feel of it though!

2 Likes

That’s a testament to @tomiboi’s fine handwork

3 Likes

Very nice! I still love your earlier design made of folded metal.

1 Like

I actually liked the design of that a lot but I think the folded metal structure wouldn’t be ideal for the swingarm setup, and from what i learnt, these wheels definitely need some sort of deck flex to work. And ideally that is some controlled and adjustable flex by a suspension, like the current bushing style swingarms or maybe an even more advanced suspension. At this point, I need to test and play with suspension settings to know what’s best. Having a pretty capable mill will make prototyping that way easier.

Also I kinda like the ability to make everything inhouse, and cutting up large steel sheets inhouse I wouldn’t be able to do in my 14-16 sqm / 150-170 sqft to fit everything workshop related plus my computer, and there is a limited budget.

So with a design like this it seems like the suspension dampening could lead to your effective truck angles changing depending on how much the bushings are compressing

I’ve noticed on my flexy hellhound duality setup this leads to me being able to kinda snap the board out of corners by pushing harder, causing the angles to increase and the turning to become sharper as a result, is this something you’re trying to do? Or is this more of a byproduct of the suspension design? Do you think this could induce a level of unpredictability into the setup?

1 Like

I’m going specifically for that feel. And I want the amount of it to be adjustable, hence the radium style swingarm design. Increased truck in the turn is a good thing. Especially with the kart wheels, that’s something to play with mid corner.

Essentially this has the opposite effect of slip angle (the more you push the less you turn vs the more you push the more you turn). A setup that doesn’t have either feels awful and that’s why my setup for the Prague race felt so bad compared to what I have now. But a setup that has both doesn’t feel very predictable, hence the common misconception that flex is bad. You need either or.

It’s happening! More info will follow soon. Still have a couple hours of driving to get home. In total close to 1900 km/ 1200mi of driving with an 80km/h 50mph rated trailer.

Still have about 350 km to home, and I am VERY MUCH looking forward to get out of the car.

10 Likes

So, I just acquired this machine from 1988, it’s a Kuhlmann Prokomat P20T with 400x400x100 travel. New price (in 1988) was 65000€, I paid 1400+ had to transport it myself (this is harder than it seems). It’s semi disassembled. Also it’s an engraving machine not a mill (technically), which is something that I plan to address. But first, story time!

This is actually a weird size because it isn’t the full fledged industrial milling powerhouse, but also way better than a hobby grade machine. Which is exactly what I was looking for, capable, needs a bit of work, but most importantly I can fit it through a door (even though it’s not easy).

I was told that the machine is about 800kg/1750lbs. The exact number is somewhere in the documentation. I got like 10kg paper based documentation with it all in german. I’ll need to dig myself into that which I am very not looking foward to very much.

So, to the transportation part. The machine is in south Germany while I live in Denmark.

A 9 hour drive away, right? Very wrong… With a trailer, going slow, taking brakes to regenerate the my brain cells that I lose every moment driving slow… it’s an insanely long drive. So I went to pickup the trailer:

Turns out the company didn’t have the pallet lifters that their website said they have

Which is what I was counting on to load the trailer. When I found this out, I was 23 hours away from the discussed time to pickup the machine. So that meant I went to buy some material for a ramp:

24m of square steel tubing

And a full sheet of plywood plus bricks to put under the trailer to support it while loading, so that it doesn’t flip.

Here’s the rough plan:

Now onto welding.

Yes I know right outside the house isn’t the perfect setup to weld…

But the weld quality turned out decent I think when I was actually paying attention. The ramp turned out a bit crooked, which isn’t an issue, though it definitely shows that at least having flat ground would be really great…

Now to load the ramp into the trailer and start driving:

We are at T-8 hours and no sleep. Remember google maps saying 9 hours? Well that didn’t think about the slight inconvience of a trailer.

So I arrive at T+6.5 hours, taking 14.5 hours on the drive that way, with one hour sleep halfway on the side of the highway, just to reset my body clock. Then we load everything, it took 4 persons to push the wheeled pallets up the ramp, but it was doable.

The rear suspension sits a little low with around 1.3 tonne of trailer weight (most of which is supported by the trailer wheels, but still.

Quick stop at the supermarket for some sugar for the way back, then onto driving. I started driving from the supermarket at 8pm, arrived to biltema just after the danish border to pickup an engine crane at around 2:30pm the next day, so that’s another 16.5 hours in the car, of which I slept 2, again on the side of the highway. The handling of the car felt horrible with so much weight behind, so I was driving extra carefully and slowly. After biltema an hour and a half of extra driving to get home.

Here’s what I bought at biltema. The engine crane is required for assembly, and turned out to be required for moving the parts of the machine into the house also. With the engine crane and trailer rental and fuel and ramp I paid around 800€ on transportation! That’s actually quite significant and I was expecting around half of that.

Also look at that electronics:

It’s ancient stuff! The keyboard and the joystick for the controls feels suprisingly nice, definitely keeping that. I guess that’s what 65000€ of late 80s money gets you, keyboard that feels nice after 35 years. :laughing: The rest of the electronics setup I want to go through and take a deeper look to find out what’s usable and what isn’t really.

Then onto unloading, which I needed to do right after arriving home. So I started driving to get the trailer 10am wednesday and was going like a machine until saturday midnight, that’s 62 hours. Expecting to wake up to return the trailer by 7am, but I slept through all 10 alarms I set, so I returned it 5 hours late around noon. Then came home and slept again until 6pm.

For unloading we used the ramp and some straps, it wasn’t a big issue. Then we took the parts inside, the bridge and the huge table we needed to flip 90 degree to fit through the door, which we did with the engine crane.

The parts for now are resting on the kitchen floor, and assembly will continue monday. This is the kind of stuff that I cannot work on alone.

The table is in my room flipped on it’s side. When I measured out where I want the table to be, I didn’t think of a huge computer hanging off the side of it, so now I am exploring another potential layout which should accomodate that better. I don’t technically need that on the machine, but having everything CNC control related attached to it wouldn’t be a bad thing, and I like the industrial look. I need decide the final position until monday.

Edit: yep, this is what I’ll be going with. It also gives access to the back of the machine which might be useful sometime. And keeps the U shape floor space to move around, which gives the most usable space in this small room.

What needs to be done to the machine:

  • Assembly: mechanical parts are relatively straight forward. With the stock electronics I’d definitely need to read documentation (in german) so that’s difficult. I was planning on refreshing the control setup anyways, so probably not even worth it to play much with the 35 year old motion control setup. The stepper motors are huge, so I want to look into their documentation to see if I can keep them. Their driver is a 3U rack unit, so there’s definitely meat in the setup. I was originally considering using my nema23 closed loop steppers but they look like a joke compared to what’s on the machine now. So I need to figure out how to communicate with the drivers and see how good the motors are.
  • So as mentioned above the motion control setup
  • Spindle: as I said above, this is an industrial engraving machine. The weight and good construction makes it very rigid to mill stuff, but the spindle is for engraving, doesn’t really work for milling. This means its a very high RPM spindle (60.000 rpm!) and very low torque. Milling would need much higher torque and less RPM. So a spindle change is needed. I am looking into options. Thinking either trying my luck with a cheap BT30 kit or just getting a relatively cheap 2.2kw chinese spindle to get started and upgrading to proper ATC spindle later down the line.
  • Z travel. It has 100mm stock, but bridge clearance from table is 220mm. The Z uses a leadscrew instead of ballscrews and the leadscrew also looks relatively worn (on the XY axis, theres ballscrews and I got extra ballscrews for the future). So since the spindle mod means taking things apart at the Z axis anyways, I’ll figure out how to increase travel, and get a new ballscrew kit to go with it for the new travel. I am aiming for 180mm Z travel after the mods, though if I can get slightly more, I’ll.
  • Enclosure: I definitely want to keep the chips enclosed. I’ll DIY something probably from acryllic and alu extrusions. This needs to happen before I first mill anything.
  • Some kind of chip clearing setup is definitely planned but I first want to have something that works and then look into chip clearing. Compressed air is cheap and works, a mist system would be better, or flood coolant would be ideal but messy and more work and need to look into if I can fit that to this machine.
  • Buy some endmills and stuff, but that’s straightforward.

I am considering making a separate build thread to document my CNC journey with this thing!

16 Likes

For… doing lines of powder to keep yourself awake?

Why pay for something new when you can spend the same amount of money for a broken machine and extra tools😁

Congrats on your new machine!

4 Likes

I ate nearly a kg of this stuff on the way back, that would be like 300g sugar

Plus some bakery stuff also

Actually with a new machine I still would’ve needed the engine crane haha. And the new machine would’ve needed to come disassembled otherwise it wouldn’t have fit through the door. Something with comparable weight and rigidity would’ve cost at least 15k new even if we ignore the door problem. I am slightly over 2k now, maybe 3-3.5k when it runs, and 5-7k when it’s done done.

Super excited to get it running!

7 Likes

Herzen Sterne Brezeln but only eat Brezeln because they are the best chocolate wise.

1 Like

Crazy mission dude!! Def deserves its own thread, this will be a saga!!

4 Likes

It’s in one piece, will be making the build thread soon! Not running yet of course.

Can’t wait to make some parts! Both for myself and for sale. Not sure if I announced it publicly yet (definitely hinted at it and definitely shared it to some people privately), but I’ll be opening a shop soonish. Once the kart wheel chassis (essentially the next revision of this build) tests well, I’ll be making them for sale also.

8 Likes

That poor carpet

Going to get filled with so many metal shavings😂

4 Likes

It’s linoleum floor (over concrete) and then a layer of rubber mat and wood to distribute the pressure, then the machine.

There will be an enclosure made before I make any chips :grin:

1 Like