Some New FOCers (84V VESC 6 based controllers)

That’s why I asked what you think would be the main advantage of your version of a dual controller. Would it be significantly smaller and cheaper to produce?

Stupid idea to the single design, maybe but just came in my head. Would it be possible to place the CAN ports as well as the main power ports to the end of the pcb, like on both sides so that it would be easy to just plug/solder a bridge between the pcbs to have a solid connection for the CAN bus and need only one xt90 plug and wire for both vescs main power supply? :thinking:

2 Likes

I’ve always thought about a perforated PCB that had traces that crossed both halves but when you broke it apart, it was two separate and fully functional single-motor ESCs. And it could even come in a four-motor variant that could be broken apart into four single motor ESCs or if, for example, motor 3 died, you could stick a new single in that place and keep the old 1,2,4 controllers

6 Likes

Absolutely! Put two separate ones on an alu plate for increased thermal mass. Dual controller :ok_hand:

10 Likes

This :smiley:

7 Likes

I just want a single one for E.V Adventure :smile::smile:

2 Likes

Hi, I’ve just signed up to allow me to write on this forum. I’ve been aware of the VESC controllers for a while but not found a VESC off the shelf controller that fits my requirements. I’m building my first ebike which is reasonably high powered. I’m using a Sabvoton controller which is ok but no support from the Chinese manufacturer, so no ability to cusomise or repair. I’ve been an arducopter user and have been used to the community support. I am looking forward to this hardware becoming available for me to build my ebike to my requirements. Perhaps in the future even a full size electric aircaft. Much appreciation for your work.

5 Likes

Did anyone else picture an old barn door open and a diy helicopter being pulled out when reading full size electric aircraft😂

Pack a parachute!

4 Likes

Diddy FETs in the ARC200, not the voltage you’re planning but the AMPS are there with the right cooling (200 constant requires water) and it’s tricky

https://endless-sphere.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=97340

2 Likes

For higher voltage there is also this huge thing :sweat_smile:
https://vesc-project.com/node/339

I’d rather go with @shaman design thou…

1 Like

I remember that coming up, massive yeah has to be! Useless to anyone but that Overkill build guy

Hate to admit it but yeah unless you really want to share a MCU & save $5, not sure there is any point.

The ESCape came in dual heatsink mode as well as single and went pretty viral till Stewii disappeared.

3 Likes

A matzo cracker ESC would not end up in any warranty claims whatsoever

/s

3 Likes
6 Likes

The new version is smaller, still crazy:

http://teamtriforceuk.com/a200s-v2-1/

3 Likes

Sounds like a deal to me. Save $5 so if you ever have an ESC failure you loose brakes on the other side as well. $5 well saved. Streetface reward.

5 Likes

God I wish I had time to work on something like this. I am a pretty good programmer, but I am just so damn busy with college & my business.

2 Likes

@b264 keeps saying it over and over: “Overspecialize and you breed in weakness.”

3 Likes

I plan on ordering pcb’s for the a200s and build this thing next. Its for my electric paramotor project:

1 Like

I think you should make both.

I think there will always be scope for budget ESCs with fewer features than som. Not everyone needs the features or has the budget (let alone patience) to buy a Unity. As someone who has fried multiple Vescs, I would definitely be looking at something that is reliable and not super fragile

1 Like

A200s (left) or A200s v2 (right)?
https://vesc-project.com/comment/2959#comment-2959