Failsafe for Battery Pack

Ive been toasting many batteries in my build and mostley due to poor management and monitoring.

My pack is 12s4p Samsung 30Q, using a much battered duck board base and a few different BMS’s. Im finding that no matter how carefully I balance a section of that pack that had just been toasted, another seems to fail and im replacing an (S) of 4 each time.

Ive charged each pack to within 0.1v @ 4.16 for the majority of the remaining packs. Where can I improve failure or am I running the board down too far? If so can I change the VESC settings to prevent min Volt?

Thanks

These cells are pretty notorious for early failures. I suspect its because once upon a time they were pretty much the best available and a lot of the cells marketed as 30Q were probably cheap fakes. Or they could all just be shit. But it’s not uncommon to see a 30q pack fail prematurely.

How confident are you that the pcb and the bms’s you have used are actually doing their job properly?

Have you tested all the traces on the pcb for continuity?

Can you please define what you mean by ‘toasted’?

This is widely considered as bad practice. New cells perform differently than used cells and can cause serious issues for your overall battery health.

The older used cells will undoubtedly drain and charge faster than the new cells, due to their depleted capacity. This can very quickly cause a voltage imbalance between each group and assuming you are bypassing the bms for discharge can potentially mean that you are running older cells below safe discharge limits every cycle.

With all of the above taken into consideration, the only course of action I would recommend is to safely recycle the entire pack and start fresh.

4 Likes