PROJECT: ENDGAME a karting inspired raceboard's development fighting the laws of physics

So, how do I start. Over the last year or so, since I finished the first iteration of RaceBro, I’ve been taking racing fairly seriously, been constantly upgrading my setup, trying to make it out to as many events as I could, and practice a lot. I’ve improved my riding skills heaps along the way, with just recently making it to the pro finals at esk8con on the most recent iteration of RaceBoi:

This journey of racing and building is well documented in the thread RaceBoi, which has by now grown itself to over 600 posts. That thread has also shown my lack of self control skills for building esk8s - I’m always striving for what I consider at the time the best thing that I can possibly have. And this brings us to the name of the board: PROJECT: ENDGAME. Firstly, this is so far, just a project. That has been going on for some time now and will continue to unfold over the rest of this year. Secondly, endgame. I’m hoping that by getting ahead of where every other setup is now, I can finally make a setup, that I just can’t upgrade anymore, because there’s absolutely nothing that can be upgraded on it, everything is top notch, even by my ever-evolving standards.

Since about last December, I’ve been working on a new project that’s much larger in scope which I’m hoping brings real innovation to the esk8 racing scene. The main idea with this project, is to take all the tire development that the kart racing scene has received, and fit them on an esk8. But you can’t just fit 10x4.5" tires on any esk8 and expect it to feel good, you’ll be standing way too high off the ground. You need a chassis designed from the ground up to make this happen in a way that’ll feel good on the track. Before we dive into it too deep, be aware, this WILL be a long read.

Trucks

First a little bit about trucks. I’ve tried all kinds of trucks over the years, and Dualities by @Titoxd1000 are the best ones that I’ve ridden on so far, hands down. They achieve a precise zero slop feel, they take any regular skate bushings (including WFB), they are easy to work on and can change bushing setups within minutes. So Dualities it is. But what width? Well, the kart wheels are so wide and so offset, that I want to minimize hanger width, so I went with 240mm for now. And tried to design all clearances around that.

Wheels

Now, lets talk about the wheels, as the whole project is centered around fitting them. Full size racing kart front wheels are most commonly 10x4.5-5, so that’s the target. It’s as small as the best kart wheels can get, unfortunately going any smaller would mean compromises in tire compound. Chronologically the exact tire choices were only decided later on, so for now lets talk about how to fit the rims.

The custom MBS pattern BRP hub development from @Ac53n has given me a good start with a wheel hub - the original plan was a chassis that can swap between BRPs and kart wheels in a fairly short amount of time, so I went for these. If you stack these fully with bearings, you end up with an insanely wide bearing spacing, and they are adaptable to many setups. More about my exact bearing setup a little later, but for now the important part is that the sheer size of these wheels require me to run a very wide bearing spacing, which these do support. Afterall, they were designed to run on 17-20mm shafts, not 12mm.

At around the same time these were being designed, I found a set of kart rims which have a fairly rare 55mm centering bore, instead of the much more common 40mm centering bore of 5" rims. This is important, because this is what we needed to be able to have the BRP pattern and the kart rim pattern on one part. Meet the Righetti Ridolfi KC70AL125-67. 5" wide, 5" diameter, 55mm centering, 3x67mm M8 bolt pattern.

So, these obviously don’t just bolt together, what’s up with that? Tommy designed up an adapter for me, which gives the rims the least amount of offset possible, so they stay supported as much as possible, while still having a little bit of the bearing left for the wheel spur. Huge thanks again! I’ve got two sets of these machined, hoping to be able to swap between different tires (for example practice and race tires) within a reasonable timeframe. Or for example if I get a flat mid race I don’t want to swap tires on rims between heats, I can swap them with the BRP pattern screws.

In the middle, this can also take bearings for extra support.

So a bit about that bearing spacing now. From hanger to axle nut, this is the plan:

hanger - 1mm speedring - 28x12x12 wide double row angular bearing 3001 - 6001 regular bearing - 22.2mm spacer - 6001 regular bearing - 6001 regular bearing - axle nut. There’s 1mm extra left after the nut for perfect nylock engagement, and the Tito Dualities 68.5mm axle length is pretty much fully stacked with 58mm total bearing spacing.

Another idea that I had just recently, but might require 270 hangers, is to mill a 30mm or 35mm bearing mounting interface for the 22^2 R6 motor mount part which would take an oversized gear bearing, and shift the wheel to the insides a bit, freeing up axle length on the outside of the wheel which could be used for extra bearings for an even wider total bearing spacing (including the spur’s bearing).

Everything was test printed when the tire arrived, and it went all together, signaling that these parts are ready to be ordered from metal.

Tires

Well, I have to talk about these too, even though I am yet to ride them. The main goal of this project was running top notch tires. For now I’ve got two sets of discontinued Bridgestone YPB softs to go through, as I’ve got an 83% off deal on them. These are close to what I’ve wanted to run anyways, but not the final tire choice. Given that my board is not as heavy as a gokart, and that esk8 racing is harder on my body than karting, I decided to go for super soft compounds, as I probably wouldn’t be able to overheat them anyways. The tire that I really want to try later on are Lecont LPM, they are the grippiest tire in karting right now, and they have stiff sidewalls, which I think is what we want in an esk8. Oh and I think this is the perfect place to throw in a size comparison to more normal tires:


Linnpowers (6.5") CST C190 slicks (9x3.5"), kart setup (10x4.5")

These kind of super soft compound tires are specifically made for the higher power karts, this one is for the 50hp KZ category, as they are known to bog down rental engines too much. Another reason for an electronics upgrade.

Also rest assured there will be custom gear drives in this project, but now lets get to the chassis itself, now that we know the constraints that I’m designing around - the wheels and the trucks.

The chassis

Well, a raceboard has to be stiff and rigid so that the inputs by the rider are translated directly to steering. That calls for an all metal chassis. Also I’m not super experienced with welding, but I can weld somewhat. This made me want to avoid the V5 style tubular steel chassis. Let’s come up with something new, what are cars made of? Sheet metal. Let’s see if I can make that work. I can design for the parts to be able to take most of the load without welds already, and then the welds just make sure everything stays in place and add strength - they aren’t as critical in my design as in a V5 or something like that.

The design work for this chassis started months ago already. I set out a couple goals in the beginning: adjustable ride height, by a large range, being able to go down as close to the ground that I can scrape. (Mostly) top mount, with space in the frame for a few components - ESCs, and a small part of the battery. Standing platform length that suits my stance. Then as time went on, I also added the goal of an adjustable standing platform length, which can be used to shorten the total wheelbase by a fairly large amount. This last goal might be scrapped if it turns out not to be strong enough in FEA (finite element analysis). Early stages looked something like this:


Then I realized how I can make those ugly square towers look better:



Then recently I decided to get rid of that ugly pelican while also making the standing platform adjustable length, and making the bellypan capable of taking the makerx G300 ESCs:


That’s where I currently am with the chassis, I want to confirm a few dimensions part fitment wise and get it through FEA, other than that, I think I’m happy with it. Oh and possibly trying to shave off some weight if I can. It’s gonna be HEAVY, enough so that it justifies an electronics upgrade.

Electronics

So, lets talk about electronics. It will start running on my RaceBoi electronics in the beginning, so 2x D100S, 21S4P P42A, 2x 6385, 2x 6395 reachers. Then, I’ve got a cruiser board planned which would need one of the D100S, and then 2x G300s would go in. Roughly at this time, I’d also build a 20S6P battery for this board, 15S6P on top in the middle, 5S6P under. Tabless cells of course. After that the remaining D100S would also be swapped to 2x G300 as funds allow.

Then, it will be time for new motors. But while I still run the reachers, let’s discuss the gear drive I designed up for the reachers.

Gear drives

Well, there were a couple design requirements. First of all, I wanted to be able to make everything cheap on a laser, the wheel spur was cut on a laser too. Secondly, ratio should be able to gear me down to 80 km/h or 50 mph. Thirdly, somewhat enclosed.


I ended up getting a set of clamps from Tito, designing my mounts around those clamps, which is just a lasercut aluminium plate, then designing a 3D printed cover and a spacer that mounts to the side of the gear. The gear itself is lasercut chromoly 4130 from sendcutsend, not as nice as hobbed gears, but it does the job and it’s cheaper. They do appear to have a different sounds profile and maybe even a bit louder compared to the stooge open gears.

There was another design requirement, and that’s quite a strange one: the kart rim needs to run inverted for the proper offset, which makes the valve stem face towards the inside, rather inconvenient. I designed the gears and the mounts so that I have plenty of space to pass a valve extender through the whole assembly, so that I can inflate my tires without having to disassemble the board.

Back to electronics - motor upgrade

So, all the cool guys are moving to inrunners nowadays. I’ve got a couple challenges - I don’t want to move below 20S, so 600ish KV is out of the question. And I also absolutely hate the look of staggered motors like the new stooge setups.

I’ve found these long boi SSS motors, that are nearly as long as the distance between my mounts, so I can print like 20mm spacer or whatever and then it looks like two full length cylinders.

At 330KV this motor is rated for 75V, so what could go wrong if I do 20S. I intend to only charge to maybe 3.8-3.9V or so per cell, so that hundreds of amps of regen won’t cause that much damage to the battery. So close enough to that voltage rating, and not like I’ll ever be riding top speed anyways. Rated for 14kW constant 20kW peak per motor I’ll be able to gear to top speeds I can never reach and still have infinite torque. Probably doing a ratio of 12:1 or somewhere in the neighbourhood of that, requiring the design of a new gear drive, more on that when I actually get to it. Rated for 266A (continuous (I think)). Hoping to be able to set 400-500 phase amps on G300s and never reach it due to not having enough grip with a 60 mph gearing. Hoping to have enough torque to not need to run any power to the front for maxing out total traction, and not need to run any brake to the rear. That would mean complete freedom for tweaking my bias, without having to worry about any power compromise. And hoping to set 400+ battery amps at 20S, and never reach it because I’m not that crazy (yet).

PS: I’ve decided to break this out from the RaceBoi thread, where it doesn’t really fit that well anymore, so it’s not burried under 600 ish posts. I’ll first try to fit the kart wheels on the old chassis just because I’m impatient and can’t wait for the frame to be made, but progress regarding the new chassis will all be here in this thread.

Timeframe: Hoping to be running the wheels in May on my current chassis. Hoping to order the new chassis sometime in May, probably after having done the first ride on the wheels. Hoping to build out the first iteration on the new chassis by mid July. First pair of G300s ideally during the summer, second pair and new battery probably autumn, new gears and motors late autumn/ winter.

31 Likes

reserved

So stoked to see what comes of this project. This thing is gonna ripppppp

6 Likes

Wow. This is gonna be absolutely insane. I can not wait for thai to get built.

Best of luck. We are on the edge of our seats!

5 Likes

This is insane. Can’t wait to see how it turns out, you might be starting a new saga in the race scene.
:eyes: I’ll be watching closely

8 Likes

The thread is new but the hype continues unabated. :metal:

Regarding weight saving, have you considered just using conventional wood and composites for the deck? The weakest link for your steering response requirement should be those mounting towers, so throwing tens of kg of metal at the deck may not be the best use of that mass.
A regular flat deck can be made to have substantial torsional stability by layering composite fabrics at 45 degrees, and an integrated deck can be work as a torsion box in the same way as your metal rendering.

There were several other confounding factors in my case ofc, but as I made my 2-wheeler boards heavier, the mass of them was really dampened the feeling of being able to throw them around aggressively. Hopefully this doesn’t translate to a low slung esk8, but I see a bit of my own thought process in this project :joy: and wanted to throw my experience out there. Best of luck with the build!

12 Likes

For some reason those tires make your board looks like it’s wearing clown shoes.

6 Likes

Uhhh, you might be totally right. But I completely despise working with composites (after having tried it once and failing spectacularly partially due to my stupidity)

To be honest, my plan was to try to get FEA to run and then take off a little bit of weight from spots that don’t need it, and call it a day hoping that the extra total weight won’t be a big deal. And then hope to prove it during testing that it still handles well. My experience so far with esk8s where the axle is more or less inline with the axle doesn’t seem to suggest weight being a huge deal, but this would take heaviness to the next level. While also being sub axle quite deeply, which might introduce other weirdnesses that I potentially have to tune out. So you might be right.

A carbon tub should be able to do the job better, but I just refuse to work with composites. Another reason for this kind of construction is that I’d want to make this repeatable, I want to design something that I could potentially make more of in the future without an expensive and also hard to modify mold, if I want to make adjustments to the design. But also without necessarily having to put down 2-3 grand for each with CNC milled parts, like for a psychoframe.

Honestly, I do have a couple cool ideas if I were to redesign the body part of it, but it remains to be seen how much weight I could actually save.

One thing is for sure, I could make the most weight saving by giving up the adjustability. But this being a first of its kind prototype, I am not sure if giving that up as weight saving is a good idea or not.

If I don’t figure out something else then perhaps the solution to weight is just to make one heavy but adjustable frame, test the hell out of all the options, settle on one setting, and make a lightweight frame around that geometry.

7 Likes

Super cool project! Looking forward to the building process and seeing the final result.

7 Likes

Let’s fucking gooooo. Stoked to see how this turns out. The weight of your chassis might end up helping warm the tires.

But let’s be real, even after you finish this there’ll still be new things to try :smirk:

3 Likes

Huh I didn’t even think of that but that’s totally true. However. Gokart tires are supposed to be brought up to temperature much slower compared to esk8 tires, even on karts it sometimes takes a couple laps until they are fully up to temperature. Well, on an esk8 a race is a couple laps. I’m pretty sure that I’ll need to get some proper tire warmers for these later down the line.

I’m hoping to finally try the tires in probably about two weeks, so we will see.

Hey, let my wallet believe there’s an end to this at some point :face_with_peeking_eye:

Jokes aside, if there’s any improvements I can think of, rest assured I’ll make it happen.

6 Likes

Tires are all mounted to the rims. A heatgun is pretty much necessary for these tires to mount up. I am realllly hoping the first set can survive the whole trip to Prague, as unmounting these will require me purchasing a tire press which I just don’t immediately want to spend 100€ on. That said, I’m probably still taking the extra set of tires with me just in case.

And hubs should be here on Tuesday!

15 Likes

So, the prototype set of hubs from @Ac53n are here and I couldn’t stop myself from immediately throwing something together when I should’ve worked on my bachelor thesis instead.

Machining quality is really nice on these!

Juuuuust enough axle left.

Well, in the front. The rear I needed an extra spacer for motor clearance but should still work.

Clearance between the motors I think less than 1mm now. Perfect.

Tires looking huge.

Finished the bare minimum required work to run these just in time so we could go out for a session with my friend.

The 9x3.5 looks small next to these monstrosities.

Ride height… Doesn’t look great, but honestly, short track, I didn’t really feel being high off the ground being an issue. Definitely not as big of an issue as I thought it will be. That said. I definitely want to try being closer to the ground.

Pebble collection is definitely working. Completely unrideable without a visor. And I didn’t even heat them up that much yet.

Soooo, how do they feel? First impressions are really promising.

But. Today I was geared for maybe 90 mph / 140+ km/h. Need to change gearing from 22T to 12T, which should put me back to around 50mph/ 80km/h. Right now I have zero torque. I did however also feel the tires bogging down the sk8 during turning - what I mean by this, is that turning makes me scrub off speed. Expected for not running the same angles front to back. But karts get around this by having a fixed axle and lifting the inner wheel in a turn. We have different vehicle dynamics and essentially an open diff - I do think I need more throttle to turn with these then with normal wheels. Or maybe this is just something I feel now due to having zero torque. We will see how next session goes.

Another issue, is foot bite. I suprisingly have very limited wheelbite - on the deck. But my shoes bite pretty bad, which needs pretty much immediate fix. Extenders it is, hopefully I can throw something together within the next few days. I also happen to have some 1" square tubing from steel that I can use the reinforce the deck against flex if it gets out of control, but that’s extra time, effort, and creativity that I need to put in maybe even right away.

The foot bite however makes comparisons harder to make, as it literally didn’t allow me taking anything close to my usual lines. However, at this very low torque, I felt I need to take it much wider anyways. But this does make comparisons harder to make with my one session experience on these.

But how did they feel ignoring these inconveniences? Well, first I did two light warmup laps (T-race), then started pushing it, and first serious corner slid out like I might as well be riding on ice. Then I did more chill warmup laps and started pushing it again. Now it felt great. Ambient temp was maybe 13C / 55F somewhere around there, but forgot to take temp gun to see tire temps. So these definitely need more warmup, noted. Maybe into like lap 8 where they had good enough heat buildup so the formula started working well, I had great grip. Probably about on par to hard Supernovas at this point. Then I reached grip limit. Right around when the grip topped off, I could feel the tire vibrating, skipping on the asphalt. But at this point I still felt solid grip - essentially giving me a perfect indicator of where the limit is. Then I kept pushing for more and more laps without a break, to get more temperature into the tires. Couple more laps in, and I was trying super hard to break traction, but I was just unable. I felt like I never leaned so far into a faster larger radius corner then I did today.

Feeling the tires by hand, I think for the very little amount of power my board could put down today, temps weren’t too bad. They definitely weren’t hot, but they had reasonable heat buildup over many laps, and once the heat was in the tire, it felt great.

I’m very excited for when I can fix the gearing and foot bite, so that I’ll be able to fully push these. So far, they are great.

One more thing though, I felt like as if they did make my steering a bit more progressive then it used to be on small tires. But it didn’t feel like it was a huge effect. But I need to resolve setup issues before I can say more.

Oh and just to note. These are manufactured 5 years ago, which does probably make the rubber harder than it should be. And also I had opened the packaging on them 4 months ago, and stored them in open air, which definitely made the rubber harder, I can feel that with my nails. I do have a second set from the same batch still in packaging though. But it’s worth noting that I was supposed to store the tires with cling film covering them, so that the oils inside the rubber pores cannot evaporate - for tires like this, this does matter. I think once I’m through these two sets and get some newly manufactured Lecont LPM tires, which by my discussion with kart racers is the best tire right now, that’ll probably feel even better.

19 Likes

I feel like with tires this big, we starting to hit that ceiling where it’s quite hard to heat up tires to their optimal temperature, especially in colder environment due to our weight. In race environment it will be even worst cause you prob won’t be able to do a couple laps right before the race start to heat up the tire enough.

4 Likes

On the other hand once they are up to temperature, they stay there and don’t cool off quickly.

I think tire warmers will be the play.

The short term plan is carving behind the track to get temperature into them, and just hope the 5 minutes or so we spend in check in before each heat doesn’t cause them to loose all heat.

Long term I’ll definitely get some proper tire warmers for them.

What I noticed though from yesterday, is that they heated up more then my 9x3.5s did that my friend was riding. That’s a good sign. And I couldn’t really push them as hard as usual due to gearing and wheelbite.

Keep in mind while the size is much larger, the durometer is very low, these are much softer than regular esk8 tires. That makes them more able to heat up. Also yet to play with pressures which is a huge thing for these. Just ran them at 10psi cold

3 Likes

Do you think that ride height is gong to be an issue? @rafaelinmissouri has a super low duality build and was scraping deck when he turned hard, your renderings appear lower than his build.

1 Like

The width of the board and the angled sides of the bellypan were all designed so that there won’t be any scraping. That said, right now the plans changed as in top priority is getting the current chassis lowered and reinforced probably with some welded square steel tubing. Doing the lowering wheelbase extender style, meaning this will solve my foot bite problems too.

Then proceed with studying for my exams. And I’ll only be able to really focus on the new chassis in the summer. Until then I might come up with new ideas that are also worth exploring.

2 Likes

Glad to see that my hubs worked out for your setup, looks crazy clean haha

3 Likes

Thanks a lot for putting in some design work to make them work! They do look really nice! :grin:

Are those hubs 5in inner diameter?